Electric cars vs hybrid cars vs plug-in hybrids
Electric, hybrid and plug-in hybrid vehicles all have their pros and cons, but which is best for you?
If you’re new to electric, hybrid and plug-in hybrid cars, you may be unfamiliar with some of the jargon surrounding the latest technology. And if that’s the case, you’re probably not really sure what the benefits and drawbacks are for each type of vehicle.
This is a big problem, because if you’re searching for a new car, you could be looking at models that don’t suit your requirements, or ones that might end up costing you a lot more money in the long run.
All are more environmentally friendly than comparable petrol or diesel cars, but it can still be hard to know which different type is best for you. There’s not a one-size-fits-all answer – it depends on how regularly you can recharge, the types of journeys you typically do and maybe even what you can afford. That’s why hybrids, plug-in hybrids and electric cars are all available.
So, in order to show the benefits and negatives of electric, hybrid and plug-in hybrid cars, we’ve put together the following guide to show you exactly how they all work. Hopefully it'll clarify some of the technical terms, and give you an idea of the type of car you'd be best suited to.
And if you scroll down to the ‘Which should I buy?’ section, we’ve laid out some things you’ll need to consider when deciding which type of ‘electrified’ car will most suit your needs.
What is an electric car?
An electric car runs solely on electricity. That’s it. No added complications or footnotes here, it really is that straightforward. You can wave goodbye to fuel-station visits and recharge at home or at a destination instead. They are sometimes referred to as battery electric vehicles (BEVs) or just electric vehicles (EVs), but they mean the same thing.
Their energy is stored in a physical battery, which typically contains hundreds, if not thousands, of individual cells. The size of a car’s battery is measured in kilowatt-hours – usually denoted as kWh – and the larger the battery, the more range an electric car is likely to be capable of. In most cases, the main battery doesn’t power functions like the radio – that’s usually taken care of by a separate ‘normal’ battery like you’d have in any other car.
The main battery is charged from an external source, almost always using a plug. You can plug an electric car straight into a standard household plug socket (an adapter may be needed), but doing this is likely to be a last resort. Household sockets typically deliver around 2.3kW of power in the UK, which means charging takes a long time. Charging a large capacity battery could take over 24 hours!
Most manufacturers recommend that you install a 'wallbox' charger for your electric car at home. These are a lot faster (capable of around 7kW in most cases) and will usually charge even the biggest batteries overnight. They're a good option to consider, and there's a Government grant that could subsidise your installation cost by as much as £500.
You may also have heard of 'fast charging' and 'rapid charging'. Both offer quicker charging times than wallboxes, although they're slightly different. Fast chargers usually deliver between 7 and 50kW of power, while rapid chargers are capable of 100kW and up. They're commonly found at car parks and service stations.
While electric cars are powered by batteries, the wheels are driven by electric motors. Some manufacturers fit a single electric motor, others opt for one at the front and one at the back, while some cars even feature one on each wheel.
Electric cars costing under £35,000 are currently eligible for a £2,500 plug-in car grant from the government, which is separate to any manufacturer offers.
What is a hybrid car?
This is where things get a tad more complicated. There are a few types of hybrid car, but all of them have one thing in common: they combine a petrol or diesel engine with an electric component to boost a car’s efficiency.
In a ‘mild hybrid’, the effect of this is minimal and only apparent at low speeds. Mild hybrids usually employ a ‘starter generator’ in place of a petrol or diesel car’s starter motor, and can recover energy from the engine when slowing down using technology called regenerative braking. A mild hybrid will aid stop-start systems and allow an engine to be switched off for longer when stationary, reducing emissions. Some models even provide a brief electrical boost when accelerating, improving a car’s fuel economy.
A full hybrid (sometimes called a 'self-charging' hybrid) is slightly different. Here, a portion of the engine’s power is used to charge a battery, which in turn powers an electric motor that can – for very short distances only – propel the car unaided. This is useful for keeping emissions to a minimum when driving around town, although at motorway speeds you’ll still rely on petrol or diesel power.
What is a plug-in hybrid car?
A plug-in hybrid electric vehicle (often called a PHEV) builds on the mild-hybrid and self-charging-hybrid technology described above with a bigger battery that – just like an electric car – can be charged using a plug.
Plug-in hybrids are capable of travelling much further on electric power alone: lots of the latest models will do around 25-50 miles without needing to use petrol or diesel. This means you could commute to work and enjoy the low running costs of an electric car, but not have any 'range anxiety' about making longer journeys.
Better still, a plug-in hybrid can also travel faster than a standard hybrid in electric only mode. Some models will do as much as 80mph under electric power, so you don’t need to stick to low speeds in order to enjoy the benefits provided by the battery.
Which should I buy?
The benefits of an electric car are numerous, with exceptionally low running costs arguably offering the most appeal. If you charge up at home on a typical electricity tariff of around 14 pence per kilowatt-hour, your car's 'fuel' bills will likely amount to around 3 pence per mile; three or four times cheaper than the most efficient petrol and diesel models currently on sale. Electric cars are currently exempt from VED (road tax), too.
However, you need to think carefully about how an electric car would work for you on a day-to-day basis before heading to the nearest dealership.
First, consider where you're going to charge your electric car, and how. If you have a driveway or garage, and you’re open to installing a wallbox charger, then great. But if you can only park on the street, or if you need to rely on a slow domestic socket to charge your car, an electric vehicle might not be for you.
Range is also a big factor to bear in mind. Depending on the model, you could have anything from 50 to 400 miles at your disposal, which in turn regulates how often you’ll need to charge, and how long a charge will take.
A small city car such as the Smart EQ ForFour – with a real-world range of 65-80 miles – might serve you well for things like the school run and the weekly shop, but would be impractical for longer journeys. So if you haven’t also got a second petrol or diesel car as a backup for those occasions, some of the limited-range electric cars are out of contention. However, lots more electric cars can manage 200 or 300 miles on a charge – such as the Kia e-Niro, Tesla Model 3 and Volkswagen ID.3.
You should also bear in mind that the UK's recharging network is still growing and improving, and many charging points at service stations and retail parks aren't yet as reliable as they need to be.
Hybrids and plug-in hybrids are alternatives if a fully electric car is out of the question. A plug-in hybrid especially could save you a lot of money, provided you can charge the battery at home or at work, and that the majority of your journeys are either short or medium distance. However, they’re often more expensive than standard petrol or diesel cars, so you’ll need to charge regularly to recoup money through low running costs.
If you're a very regular long-distance traveller or can’t charge the car frequently, then you'll feel the benefits of a plug-in hybrid less often than those doing lots of short drives. In that case, a standard hybrid would be your best bet: you’ll get the benefits of lower emissions at low speeds, but without the hindrance of a plug-in hybrid’s extra weight on longer journeys.
Electric car battery life: how to preserve your battery
What is a range extender and how do they work?
Can solar panels charge an electric car?
Sony electric car: Vision-S concept shown at CES 2021
Top 7 best hybrid and electric sports cars 2021
Are electric cars expensive to insure?
2021 Audi Q4 e-tron and Q4 e-tron Sportback: specs and prices