Kia Niro PHEV vs MINI Countryman PHEV: safety and reliability

Both cars should be safe, but the Kia has a stronger track record with owners and better warranty cover than the MINI

MINI Countryman hybrid

As with running costs and warranty (previous page), we can use the 2020 Driver Power survey as a barometer of reliability. The Niro – bundled in along with its electric and hybrid versions – achieved an impressive fourth-place finish thanks to strong scores in the vast majority of categories, no least reliability and build quality. Just 11.9% of owners reported experiencing a fault, usually with electrical gremlins. 

The Countryman didn't feature in the same survey, but MINI itself actually returned an even lower average share of owners reporting a fault with their cars – just 8%, a very strong result considering the double-digit scores of many other manufacturers. 

Safety shouldn't be a concern with either car: both are five-star rated by Euro NCAP, with the Countryman scoring 90% for adult safety and 80% for child occupant protection. The Niro (with the Safety Pack added, as on all PHEV cars) gets a 91% score for adult protection and an identical 80% rating for children.

The Niro comes as standard with 'forward collision avoidance assist' (also known as automatic emergency braking, or AEB), lane-keeping assistance and hill-start control, while the Countryman gets AEB as standard but requires some box-ticking to secure some of the features the Kia gets as standard.

Most Popular

First contact: facelifted Kia EV6 will look even more like a UFO
Kia EV6 facelift
News

First contact: facelifted Kia EV6 will look even more like a UFO

Kia is readying an update for the EV6 crossover, which is set to include a new face and tech from the larger EV9
27 Nov 2023
New Fisker Ocean Sport washes up in the UK: £36k for a 288-mile range
Fisker Ocean Sport
News

New Fisker Ocean Sport washes up in the UK: £36k for a 288-mile range

American EV startup Fisker has just launched its entry-level Ocean SUV in the UK, with a range of up to 288 miles
22 Nov 2023
New Vauxhall Vivaro Electric is cheaper, yet has more range and tech
Vauxhall Vivaro Electric - header
News

New Vauxhall Vivaro Electric is cheaper, yet has more range and tech

Vauxhall has given its Vivaro Electric panel van a mid-life refresh with a new face and some of the latest tech
16 Nov 2023