Skip advert
Advertisement

MINI Electric vs Renault ZOE: safety and reliability

Renault and MINI have strong reputation for safety; both cars should prove reliable transport

MINI Cooper

Renault is known for making safe cars, so it’s not a huge surprise to find the ZOE packed with active safety equipment: autonomous emergency braking, blind-spot warning, lane-departure warning, lane-keeping assistance and traffic-sign recognition all feature on top-spec GT Line cars – but entry-level cars are sparser in this department.

Advertisement - Article continues below

In Level 2 trim tested here, the MINI comes as standard with the ‘Driving Assistant’ pack, which brings speed-limit and traffic-sign recognition, city collision mitigation and automatic high-beam headlights. Step up to Level 3 and adaptive LED headlights are added, along with some extra parking assistance.

Renault ZOE

Neither of these cars has been crash-tested by Euro NCAP yet, but there’s not too much to worry about: the MINI’s petrol-powered counterpart achieved a four-star rating in 2014, while the vast majority of Renault’s output consistently manages five-star ratings.

As far as reliability goes, it’s hard to predict if the MINI will be particularly prone to issues as it’s such a new model; the ZOE has a longer track record. MINI didn't fare as well as Renault in the 2020 Driver Power customer satisfaction survey, with its 26th-place finish out of 30 brands a reflection of some owners’ frustrations, largely with practicality issues, but just 8% reported faults with their cars. Renault achieved a mid-table 15th-place finish in comparison, with a higher 18.7% of owners experiencing faults.

Skip advert
Advertisement
Skip advert
Advertisement

Most Popular

New Dacia Spring has landed and could be UK’s first really cheap electric car
Dacia Spring reveal - front
News

New Dacia Spring has landed and could be UK’s first really cheap electric car

Dacia Spring is coming to the UK with a new face, upgraded tech and a potential starting price of £16k
21 Feb 2024
New Ineos Fusilier plugs the ‘electric Land Rover Defender’ gap in the market
Ineos Fusilier
News

New Ineos Fusilier plugs the ‘electric Land Rover Defender’ gap in the market

Ineos’ first electric off-roader has been revealed and looks very much like the larger, petrol-powered Grenadier
23 Feb 2024
New cheap Vauxhall Corsa Electric YES Edition says ‘no’ to expensive EV prices
Vauxhall Corsa Electric YES Edition - front
News

New cheap Vauxhall Corsa Electric YES Edition says ‘no’ to expensive EV prices

New entry-level Vauxhall Corsa Electric arrives with exclusive red paintwork and a £5,500 cheaper starting price
23 Feb 2024