New Tesla Model 3 versus used Tesla Model S: driving & performance

The 75D is hilariously fast despite being one of the ‘lesser’ Model S variants, while the Model 3 feels perfectly judged for UK roads

Tesla Model S driving rear
Driving & performance rating

4.5 out of 5

Let’s get something straight: neither of these cars is slow. To say that the Model 3 is slow compared to the Model S is like stating a chainsaw is more dangerous than an axe. Both are pretty sharp.

So it is with these two Tesla marvels, but the reality is that the four-wheel-drive Model S with its dual motors and 362bhp punches up the road with a bombastic disregard for what your stomach was expecting such a heavy-feeling car to do. Given that this was, for many years, the ‘entry-level’ Model S, it feels anything but entry-level, and our tested time of 4.3 seconds from zero to 60mph backs that up.

Sure, it still delivers its shock-and-awe in the form of straight-line pace and stoic neutrality. It’s not a sports car, nor is it as textural or involving as some comparable rivals like a BMW M5 or Mercedes-AMG E63, but there’s fun to be had in the Model S, even on the most boring of roads.

The Model 3 is a very different creature. Its shorter wheelbase and the rear-wheel-drive setup of the Standard Range (the other variants get four-wheel drive and longer range) makes it feel a notch closer to a sports car than a cruiser. The 245bhp on tap feels spot-on for delivering hearty pace without being intimidating, and the way it jinks neatly through corners with predictability also makes it impressively usable on a decent country road.

It also falls short of the more entertaining handling character you can enjoy in a BMW 3 Series, or even some of the smaller performance alternatives like an Audi RS3 or BMW M2. But it's still fun in a zestier way than the more brutal Model S.

Both are accomplished commuters, with ride comfort that’s unlikely to bother you, even if you cover a lot of scruffy town roads. The Model S is perhaps a touch lumpier than you’d expect of a car with standard air suspension, while the Model 3’s chunky tyre walls and forgiving suspension do a fine job just about everywhere.

Safety

The new Model 3 gets adaptive cruise control, autonomous emergency braking, blind-spot warning and lane-keeping assistance, as well as the usual suite of airbags (not including a driver’s knee airbag). The full 'Autopilot' semi-autonomous driving mode is a £5,800 option; it means the car will stay in lane, steer and even change lane or leave the motorway onto a slip road when you indicate, provided the systems see that it’s safe to do so.

You do have to remain alert and in control – it remains only semi-autonomous, even if it's the most advanced autonomous driving mode in current mainstream production.

The Model S got fewer standard safety systems when it was first launched, but many used cars have the full enhanced Autopilot features that give it the same level of autonomy as the 3 and make it one of the safest cars around. Both scored five stars in Euro NCAP crash tests, although the S was tested under a more lenient scoring process.

Driving & performance scores

In This Review

Most Popular

Top 10 best seven-seater electric and hybrid cars 2021
Mercedes EQB
Best cars

Top 10 best seven-seater electric and hybrid cars 2021

If the regular crop of electrified SUVs and family cars don’t provide enough practicality for you, then take a closer look at the range of electric an…
24 Nov 2021
Complete guide to the BP Pulse (formerly Polar Plus) charging network
BP Pulse
Your questions answered

Complete guide to the BP Pulse (formerly Polar Plus) charging network

This is how to charge your electric or plug-in hybrid car on the BP Pulse public charging network (which was formerly known as the Polar Plus network)
24 Nov 2021
Osprey opens first of 150 new electric-car rapid charging hubs for the UK
Osprey Charging
News

Osprey opens first of 150 new electric-car rapid charging hubs for the UK

The first location in Wolverhampton has now opened, with nine more set to begin construction before the end of 2021
30 Nov 2021