MG 5 vs Volkswagen ID.3: verdict and specifications
It may not have the ID.3’s contemporary looks, but the MG 5 is the practical, comfortable and more affordable package
1st: MG 5 – 4.0 stars
While both cars here have plenty going for them, you can’t get more EV for your money than the MG 5 at the moment, especially if you’re talking about boot space. Monthly finance rates for the electric estate undercut its rival by more than enough to balance out the ID.3’s superior efficiency, too, and the MG is more comfortable around town. However, it’s worth remembering that an updated version with fresh new looks and tech is arriving later this year. Read our full review to find out more.
2nd: Volkswagen ID.3 – 4.0 stars
A second-place finish here doesn’t mean the entry-level ID.3 is without appeal. It’s more efficient than the MG, roomier for passengers and slightly better to drive. But once you look at the hatchback’s price, boot space and kit levels, it’s understandably second best in this company. Some improvements to the in-car tech and better ergonomics is all it’d take for us to consider the extra purchase price justified for the VW, though. Read our full review to find out more.
Specifications
|
Car |
MG 5 SW EV Exclusive Long Range |
Volkswagen ID.3 Life Pro |
|---|---|---|
|
List price/total as tested |
£30,445/£30,990 |
£32,200/£32,200 |
|
Engine |
Single electric motor + lithium-ion battery |
Single electric motor + lithium-ion battery |
|
Transmission |
Single-speed auto / front-wheel drive |
Single-speed auto / rear-wheel drive |
|
Battery capacity |
61.1kWh |
58kWh |
|
Power / torque |
154bhp / 260Nm |
143bhp / 310Nm |
|
0-60mph |
7.3s |
9.6s |
|
Top speed |
115mph |
99mph |
|
Charge time (wallbox/rapid) |
10hrs 15mins (0-100%, 7.4kW) / 42mins (10-80%, 80kW) |
9hrs 15mins (0-100%, 7.4kW) / 33mins (10-80%, 100kW) |
|
Claimed / predicted range |
250 / 232 miles |
260 / 252 miles |
|
BiK rate / total for 20% taxpayer |
2% / £128 |
2% / £129 |
|
Length / width / height / wheelbase |
4,544 / 1,818 / 1,521 / 2,659mm |
4,261 / 1,809 / 1,568 / 2,765mm |
|
Boot capacity (seats up/down) |
464 / 1,456 litres |
385 / 1,267 litres |
